Which Protocol to Choose?
UPDATED on August 13, 2021 to reflect the latest Netflix unblocking information.
-------
This page has been updated on March 19, 2021, to reflect the changes brought by the new VLESS+XTLS protocol based on Xray-core.
It really depends on where you are located and on what you need.
Let's go through the main pros and cons of each protocol we offer.
Recommendation: Xray, with the new VLESS+XTLS protocol, is the recommended choice for web-browsing and streaming. If you don't have access to the new protocol (mainly on intel Mac OS), the old V2ray is the recommended option. We currently do not recommend Shadowsocks as it is based on an earlier version of the protocol. Choose Eclipse for security and video conferencing, and SmartDNS for Netflix unblocking on TVs and consoles (SmartDNS only works with US Netflix).
TCP | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ❌ |
UDP | 🟨 | 🟨 | 🟨 | 🟨 | ✅ | ❌ |
ICMP | ✅ | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ |
Fast | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | 🟧 | 🟨 |
Stable | ✅ | ✅ | 🟨 | ✅ | 🟨 | ✅ |
Works in China | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | 🟨 |
Unblocks Netflix | ✅ | 🟨 (Some) | 🟨 (Some) | 🟨 (Some) | 🟧 (US) | ✅ (US) |
Web-browsing / Email | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ❌ |
Video Streaming | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | 🟨 | ❌ |
Gaming | 🟨 | 🟨 | 🟧 | ✅ | 🟥 | ❌ |
VoIP/Video Conference | 🟨 | 🟨 | 🟨 | ✅ | ✅ | ❌ |
Countries | 19 | 19 | 19 | 6 | 6 | 1 |
GLOSSARY
Stability: A measurement of the frequency of disconnections and speed fluctuations, as well as the likelihood of encountering various issues.
Gaming: A measurement of how the protocol performs when gaming. Gaming usually requires good UDP support, stable apps, and low ping (less RTTs).
Trojan started development in 2017. It attempts to imitate a normal HTTPS connection as closely as possible, with as little overhead as possible. Security is achieved using TLS as the outer layer.
It is fast, and effectively bypasses blocking by the Great Firewall, as well as firewalls in other countries such as Iran, Indonesia, and Russia. It supports both UDP and TCP. Unlike Xray, most apps support trojan, including Clash.
Because of the speed, stability, and app compatibility of Trojan, we have migrated most of our servers to this protocol.
- You need to watch Netflix or other streaming channels
- You need to connect to a wide variety of countries
- You need to connect to a specific country that is only on Xray/v2ray
- You want fast downloads and HD YouTube streaming
- Do extensive web-browsing, emails, etc.
- You want to run a UDP-based application
- You want to play online games
Don't use Trojan if:
- You need OpenVPN for security
- You are on a system that doesn't support it yet or has poor support for it
Xray is a fork of the v2ray protocol by a coder under the name of rprx on github. The fork was created on November 9, 2020, and has quickly gained popularity over these past year, passing 5,500 stars on it's github repository (as of August 2021).
The fork fixes several important issues with the original v2ray code, including enabling full UDP gaming support on the original VMESS protocol, optimization of the code (about 30% faster than the original v2ray code), and most importantly, the introduction of several new technologies, including the one we are currently using, XTLS.
The only downside is that only a minority of apps have updated their software to support Xray, so you may need to update or switch to a different app to take advantage of this new technology. But it's worth it.
Xray is fully compatible with v2ray.
Update: Xray currently has some compatibility issues with Whatsapp calls. If you need Whatsapp call support, please use the "WhatsApp" server.
We have now migrated from Xray to Trojan on most of our servers.
- YOU DO NOT, OR CANNOT RUN TROJAN
- You need to watch Netflix or other streaming channels
- You need to connect to a wide variety of countries
- You need to connect to a specific country that is only on Xray/v2ray
- You want fast downloads and HD YouTube streaming
- Do extensive web-browsing, emails, etc.
- You want to run a UDP-based application
- You want to play online games
Don't use Xray if:
- You need OpenVPN for greater security
- You are on a system that doesn't support it yet or has poor support for it
V2ray was created on September 5, 2015 as an alternative to Shadowsocks and has slowly gained popularity with users in China (the github repo now has more stars than Shadowsocks). It is more flexible than Shadowsocks, supports multiple protocols out of the box, and can effectively escape blocking by the Great Firewall.
V2ray is optimized for TCP only. It only has basic UDP support. v2ray also needs 1 RTT (round-trip time) more than Shadowsocks for it's handshake. You can eliminate this additional RTT by enabling mux support in your apps (however, keep in mind that enabling mux may bring instability in the network and reduce your streaming speed).
IMPORTANT UPDATE: We have now migrated our servers to Xray. It is much faster and more stable than v2ray. If at all possible, we HIGHLY recommend moving to Xray (unless your system does not support it at this time).
Xray is fully compatible with all v2ray setups.
- YOU DO NOT, OR CANNOT RUN TROJAN
- You need to watch Netflix or other streaming channels
- You need to connect to a wide variety of countries
- You need to connect to a specific country that is only on v2ray
- You want fast downloads and HD YouTube streaming
- Do moderate web-browsing, emails, etc.
Don't use v2ray if:
- You need to play online games
- You want to run a UDP-based application
- You need OpenVPN for greater security
Shadowsocks is one of the first protocols developped in China specifically to bypass the GFW. Development started on April 20, 2012. It's original developper was forced to stop his/her work on the project due to outside pressure. Work on the protocol continues on till this day via various forks on the original project.
Shadowsocks was the first protocol we implemented, before we had to switch to v2ray and Eclipse after it was getting aggressively blocked.
Unlike v2ray, Shadowsocks is leaner and is easy on RAM and the CPU, making it more stable under load. It has also optimized it's UDP packet transmission mechanism, making it a good option for gaming.
Because Shadowsocks is heavily censored, we need to use various mechanisms to hide the connection. Therefore, only a subset of locations are available for Shadowsocks.
- You need a simple, click-and-forget connection
- You do extensive web-browsing, email, streaming, etc.
- You want to play online games (use Netch on Windows)
- You need to do VoIP or video conferencing
Don't use Shadowsocks if:
- You want to watch Netflix or unblock streaming content (use v2ray)
- You need a specific country not supported by Shadowsocks
- You are running Linux
Eclipse is our own version of OpenVPN, modified to work in China. It has never been blocked, nor do we see it getting blocked in the near future. It runs on the official OpenVPN apps, and support all the functions of OpenVPN.
It uses 256-bit encryption, supports TCP, UDP, and ICMP protocols, and is thoroughly audited by industry experts to guarantee strong security.
The main downside of Eclipse is that it is slow. Speeds are usually between 3-12Mbps depending on the time of day and server choice (though you may get speeds of up to 25Mbps on some networks).
- You want an industry-standard VPN solution
- You need military-grade security
- You are doing light browsing, emails, streaming, etc (Eclipse can stream 720p HD)
- You need support for ICMP or other non-standard protocols
- You need Linux support
Don't use Eclipse if:
- You want a fast connection
SmartDNS is a DNS server that unblocks Netflix and other streaming channels for you. You need to register your IP for authentication and add the DNS servers into your WiFi/ethernet settings and your good to go!
NOTE: It does NOT encrypt your connection. It does NOT bypass DNS poisoning by ISPs. It does NOT bypass China's firewall. It does NOT unblock Youtube.
It only bypasses geolocation blocking by Netflix and other such streaming channels.
- You want to watch Netflix or a similar channel on a device that does not support v2ray (smart TV, console, etc)
- You want to only unblock Netflix, but don't need a VPN to bypass your local internet restrictions (i.e. you don't live in China)
Don't use SmartDNS if:
- You need to bypass your ISP/School/Country's firewall
- Your ISP is doing DNS poisoning/hyjacking on the domains you want to unblock
- You want a VPN
- You have v2ray/Shadowsocks/Eclipse running at the same time (they will conflict with each other)
Last modified 7mo ago